: Unlike the first film, where only Fuhrman seemed to understand the "deranged" nature of the character, the sequel features a cast—including Julia Stiles and Rossif Sutherland—that is fully "in on the joke".
: Reviewers have noted the "appropriately atmospheric and spooky" lighting and cinematography, which help the family home feel like its own character. Orphan: First Kill 2022
: Isabelle Fuhrman returns with a "calm, cool, and collected" performance that recaptures the character's menace while heightening the absurdity of a grown woman masquerading as a child. The Mid-Point Subversion : Unlike the first film, where only Fuhrman
: The musical choices, particularly the use of Jimmy Durante’s "The Glory of Love," add a layer of ironic charm to the violence. : Unlike the first film