The show often shifts abruptly between serious crime drama and "slapstick" comedy, which some fans find distracting and "immersion-breaking."

Supporting actors like Britt Robertson and James Lesure are frequently cited as the show's backbone, often providing a necessary grounded balance to the lead's high energy.

Critics from Variety note that Nash-Betts elevates the material, bringing a "deep well of charm" that makes the show watchable even when the writing falters.