Where To Buy Pumpkin Pie May 2026

: Legacy Pie Co. and Granny Scott's Pie Shop are popular local spots; Legacy is specifically noted for its hit pumpkin pie at family gatherings.

: Local favorites include Kerber Farm in Huntington and Hometown Bakery in Centerport. Frozen Options where to buy pumpkin pie

: A widely available and budget-friendly option usually priced between $6.98 and $10.25 . Expand map Local Bakeries Famous Shipping Origins : Legacy Pie Co

: Their traditional 12-inch pie retails for around $13.99 . Frozen Options : A widely available and budget-friendly

Available on Goldbelly for around (includes shipping). Their pies are known for a signature flaky crust and generational recipes. Michele's Pies $10–20Pie shop ClosedNorwalk, CT

For local pickup, these specific shops have earned strong reputations for their pumpkin offerings:

: Pittsburgh Pie Guy makes pies from scratch using fresh ingredients, available at local farmers' markets and for online pickup.