Unlike the greedy, abusive Steve, Ben is a dorky, sweet chiropractor struggling with his own recovery from alcoholism. Watching Jen fall for the twin brother of the man she just murdered is equal parts hilarious, heartbreaking, and deeply uncomfortable. 📈 Top 3 Most Chaotic Moments of Season 2

Just when you thought the show couldn't get any more soap-opera-esque, creator Liz Feldman dropped the ultimate twist in episode two: (also played brilliantly by James Marsden).

Jen is now the one hiding a bloody secret—she bludgeoned Judy's ex, Steve (James Marsden), to death in a fit of rage.